" I found this book to be only marginally interesting. Having never read Amish fiction before, I was really unsure of what to expect. While I did expect the story to be void of any adventure, per se, I didn't expect the story to be bland. [return]I could not relate to the character of Lettie, the mother, when she chose to leave her family behind to root around in her past and reveal her secret. I realize that in the Amish culture and faith, she would have suffered greatly had she revealed her secret within her community. However, I still thought leaving the children behind as she did was too harsh. I thought the father, Judah, was portrayed as unloving to Lettie as a means to make the reader stray down the wrong paths in figuring out Lettie's mystery.[return]I found the style of writing to be very easy to read. Despite the ease of reading, I didn't feel compelled to keep going back to this book. It read as very predictable to me.[return]I kept feeling that this book wouold have been better off as a TV movie. "
— Dottie, 2/7/2014