" Excellent narration by Derek Jacobi but I found the story itself to be a bit hit or miss. I actually enjoyed the "first" mystery more. It's the more traditional of the two Holmes and Watson find themselves in. It's also got what I think of as the perfect ending to a mystery, one that you don't see coming but makes perfect sense in retrospect. As far as the mystery surrounding the actual "House of Silk", well, I should never be ahead of the detective in a mystery and I certainly shouldn't be ahead of Sherlock Holmes but in this case, I had it figured out pretty far in advance. Still, there were plenty of entertaining scenes and it was still pretty enjoyable overall. "
— KarenF, 1/24/2014