-
“Narrator Jennifer Lim has fun with the character of Sunny, an opinionated housemaid…Lim’s narration is arch, sardonic, and swiftly paced. These qualities highlight the humor laced throughout the novel, especially when it zooms in on Sunny’s time with the Zhen family. With her lively performance, Lim places Sunny’s hopes and aspirations center stage…There are a number of other female characters, and Lim makes them as familiar as our own friends.”
— AudioFile
-
“I read What We Were Promised in a state of enchantment, immediately drawn into the longings, secrets, and very human foibles of its finely-drawn cast of characters. Both intimate and panoramic…local and universal.”
— Chloe Benjamin, New York Times bestselling author
-
“A luminous family saga.”
— Entertainment Weekly
-
“Homecomings aren’t always sweet. And for Lina and her husband, Wei, they can be outright dangerous when a long-lost brother’s return threatens to pull their family apart…This seemingly inconspicuous visit sparks generations of stories fraught with star-crossed romance, familial anxiety, and expat privilege.”
— USA Today (★★★½ out of four)
-
“From fitting in culturally, family dynamics, and self-worth, the story will resonate with anyone who is uncertain and fearful about their future.”
— Women.com
-
“An astute portrait of a staid family thrown into disarray…Tan does not explore the Tolstoyan adage that every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way but rather throws a stone into the still pool of carefully balanced domesticity. Though set within Shanghai’s Chinese-born, Western-educated repatriate community, the push and pull of family ties and rivalries could as easily occur in any place and time.”
— Shelf Awareness
-
“Tan’s talent as a storyteller clearly shines through her strong plot lines and characterization; readers will want to know more about each well-crafted player in the story, rich or poor, young or old. Verdict: A novel of class, culture, and expectations; readers who enjoyed works like Kevin Kwan’s Crazy Rich Asians will likely find Tan’s surprising and down-to-earth tale an entertaining read.”
— Library Journal
-
“Abounding in insight and deftly told.”
— Maggie Shipstead, author of Seating Arrangements
-
A
beautifully rendered debut with vivid characters who will stay with readers
long after the last satisfying page.
— Judith Claire Mitchell, author of A Reunion of Ghosts
-
The magnificence and
splendor of modern Shanghai come to life in Lucy Tan's debut novel.
— Palm Beach Post
-
If you love explorations of the American dream transplanted in Shanghai, generational sagas, and the lives of the newly rich and confused, read What We Were Promised by Lucy Tan."—Lillian Li, author of Number One ChineseRestaurant
—
-
What We Were Promised explores the question of what we owe to our country, our families, and ourselves." (—Five Spot Green Living
—
-
a beautifully
written, evocative and provocative narrative.
— All-About Romance
-
This book boasts a
very memorable cast of characters... A compelling, sensitive and thoughtful debut
that is sure to move you.
— Afoma Umesi
-
Longlisted for the Center for Fiction's First Novel PrizeNamed one of the Best of Books of 2018 by The Washington Post, Refinery 29, and AmazonA Barnes and Noble Discover Pick
—
-
What We Were Promised glows through its intimate, skillful prose. Tan's debut is a beautiful reckoning with the ever-changing definition of "home
— what it means to have, lose and find family again.
-
Charming debut novel. . . . Through a
set of fascinating characters, Tan delivers a compelling story that raises
questions about assimilation, family dynamics, and the personal reverberations
of globalization.
— National Book Review
-
Dramatic and deeply moving, this would be perfect Oscar
material.
— Crystal Hana Kim, Washington Post
-
Winner of Ploughshares' Emerging Writer award, Lucy Tan draws an astute portrait of a staid family thrown into disarray in this assured first novel. She does not explore the Tolstoyan adage of unhappy families, but rather throws a stone into the still pool of carefully balanced domesticity. With its measuring of expectation against reality, What We Were Promised showcases Tan's sharp eye for the intricacies of human relationships.
— Shelf Awareness
-
Fans of Kevin Kwan's Crazy Rich Asians series will especially enjoy What We Were Promised.
— Refinery29
-
A tightly crafted debut wrought with the
measured voice of an expert craftsperson, Lucy Tan's WHAT WE WERE PROMISED is
an exquisite exploration of class, family and self.
— Bookreporter
-
A luminous family saga
— Entertainment Weekly
-
Intriguing debut
novel. Set in Shanghai, made empathic with a multigenerational family saga,
embellished with timeless class conflict, this story entertains and
enlightens.
— Christian Science Monitor
-
The ultimate message of What We Were Promised is one all young, millennial readers can relate to.
— Bustle
-
As the narrative
jumps across decades and continents, it throws the rural villages and urban
skylines, as well as the lives of the locals and aloof expatriates, into sharp
relief. . . . All the while, Tan asks what it means to belong-to a person or a
place.
— Time
-
Against a
contemporary global backdrop, made empathic with a multigenerational family
saga, embellished with timeless servant/master (and mistress) class conflict,
Tan's debut will be entertaining - and enlightening - to savvy cosmopolitan
readers throughout the summer and beyond.
— Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center
-
Fans of Kevin Kwan's Crazy Rich Asians series will especially enjoy What We Were Promised, which takes place among a similar social set.
— Refinery 29
-
Lucy Tan is an
author to watch
— Amazon Book Review
-
With its measuring of expectation against reality, What We Were Promised establishes Tan as a new talent with a sharp eye for the intricacies of human relationships.
— Shelf Awareness
-
Tan's novel
will strike a chord with anyone who looks to the future with uncertainty.
— My Domaine
-
For book clubs that
love reading about complicated family dynamics and transitional periods, this
book will provide fodder for great conversations—Bookish
—
-
A compelling story
of class, culture, regret, and anxiety about the road not taken.
— Modern Mrs. Darcy
-
From fitting in culturally, family dynamics, and self-worth, the story
will resonate with anyone who is uncertain and fearful about their future.
— Women.com
-
Readers may identify
with one or more of the characters as they deal with historic cultural norms
and modern reality—Forsyth Woman
—
-
Tan's talent as a storyteller clearly shines through her strong plot lines and characterization; readers will want to know more about each well-crafted player in the story . . . . A novel of class, culture, and expectations; readers who enjoyed works like Kevin Kwan's Crazy Rich Asians will likely find Tan's surprising and down-to-earth tale an entertaining read.
— Library Journal
-
I read What We Were Promised in a state of enchantment, immediately drawn into the longings, secrets and very human foibles of its finely-drawn cast of characters. Both intimate and panoramic, Lucy Tan's debut is a revealing consideration of modern China as well as a thrilling discovery of the generations-long secrets between two families. Compassionate and heartbreaking, funny and wise, local and universal, What We Were Promised marks the arrival of an inspiring new voice.
— ChloeBenjamin, author of The Anatomy of Dreams and The Immortalists
-
Lucy Tan brings to vibrant life the self-made, newly cosmopolitan Zhens, who have gone from the tea fields and silk factories of small town China to the luxury high rises of Shanghai in one generation. Abounding in insight and deftly told, What We Were Promised is a story both sweeping and intimate, as this most modern of families discovers they must confront their past in order to find their future.
— Maggie Shipstead, author of Seating Arrangements and Astonish Me
-
"What We Were Promised is a big beautiful novel. Lucy Tan's dazzling debut grapples with the persistence of the past, the inevitability of the present, and the difficulty of balancing individuality with community.
— Hannah Pittard, author of Visible Empire and Listen to Me
-
In What We Were Promised, Tan skillfully brings to life the issues of modern day China and Shanghai. It is an immigrant story but one that also delves into the subject of going back to one's homeland. Tan humanizes each and every one of her characters. There is also depth to how the stories of past and present are interwoven. As a reader I felt that I was in good hands.
— Weike Wang, author of Chemistry
-
A
quietly brilliant book, and a truly singular debut.
— ArnaBontemps Hemenway, award-winning author of Elegyon Kinderklavier
-
Status, family
dynamic, and gender roles plague the characters and they must ponder, what
'they owe to themselves, each other, and their country.
— Women.com
-
It has plenty of
literary heft and timely social commentary, but it's also a thoroughly
enthralling and deeply moving novel
— Isthmus
-
addicting books to read if you loved Crazy Rich
Asians
— Hello Giggles
-
an elegant debut novel
— Newark Star Ledger