The War That Killed Achilles: The True Story of Homer's Iliad and the Trojan War Audiobook

" Nice, in-depth reading of The Iliad. However, the author as biased towards Achilles as I am to Hector. So in my opinion she is a bit too invested in portraying Achilles in the best possible light and completely glosses over Achilles' horrific treatment of Hector's corpse. "

" A must read for every fan of Homer's great work. This pulls it all into place. "

" I read this for a book discussion; it's not something I'd have picked up. Doubtless it was a better book than I appreciated, so I'm giving it one more star than I was inclined to. "

" Great for students required to read The Iliad. Explains everything in an easy to understand way. "

" This book really piqued my curiosity since I've read the Iliad a few times. It was ok. Not bad, but really, just read the Iliad - No great revelations to be found in this book. The point made is obvious in the Iliad itself: was is devastating and horrible. Caroline Alexander's premise is that the Iliad is an anti-war epic - but the treatment seems thin and slightly unfocused. The preface states: "This book is about what the Iliad is about; this book is about what the Iliad says of war." Therefore, again, my recommendation: read the Iliad instead. It's better, more interesting, and exciting. You can skip this one entirely, it disappointed. "

" A really excellent, thoughtful reading of the Iliad. Her thesis is basically that Homer intended to show the pointlessness of war, but the real value is in walking the reader through the plot of the Iliad and pointing out little touches that might otherwise go unnoticed. Highly recommended. "

" I enjoyed this step-by-step analysis of the experience of war in the Iliad, but I'm not quite sure that it lives up to its description. At times, it felt more like someone offering a "greatest hits" commentary on the action of the poem. Enjoyable and insightful, but I lost the focus at times. "

" This analysis of The Iliad gave me many new insights into that great work, and did so with good scholarship, poignancy and occasional humor. A fascinating book! "

" 4 stars for all the things I learned from this book. Her main point is repeated too bluntly a few too many times - it could have been a shorter book. But generally it's well written, and brings together a lot of research. "

" Have we reached such a cultural nadir that it is "groundbreaking" to hammer (with excessive quotations from an old translation and recaps for the attention deficit) that the Iliad is about a war, and wars are timeless and sad. Really? "

" The war that killed Achilles is everything a history lover mixed with a Homer fan could want. It has a lucid style, makes suggestions that are clearly plausible and well-researched, and has a healthy respect for the oral tradition behind Homer-as-we-know him. "

" if you've ever read the Iliad, then read this book to get a new perspective. Or you might read the Iliad once you've read this book. great insight and research. "

" Over-regurgitated information provided by a floundering Richmond Lattimore lover. "

" An excellent dissection of the epic classic and its elemental echoing throughout the history of human warfare, as well as the effects of war upon those who are forced to experience it. Very expertly written. "

" My favorite topic in literature. this is the best short analysis of The Iliad I have read. "

" I love Homers books but this analysis of the story of Achilles was dry and boring and the best parts were the quotes from the stories themselves. I did not learn anything new from reading this book. "

" I listened to this book. A wonderful experience. Listened to some parts multiple times. Great way to enjoy the classical commentary. "

" This was an excellent book. If you love The Iliad, you will love this book. "

" Yet another excellent book by the author on the 2 great books about navigation... endurance and Voyage...covering The Bounty and Endurance. Plus great insight into the great poem and tale of the Iliad "

" This book really breaks down the Iliad, which helps to understand the translation from the original text. Very good! "

" A really excellent, thoughtful reading of the Iliad. Her thesis is basically that Homer intended to show the pointlessness of war, but the real value is in walking the reader through the plot of the Iliad and pointing out little touches that might otherwise go unnoticed. Highly recommended. "

" I don't know if I'm too busy right now, just not in the right, or if this book is a little mind numbing. I am willing to take the blame, but I didn't particularly enjoy this book. "

" A story that's been told since 700 BC must be powerful. Caroline does a wonderful job explaining the plot, humanizing the the characters, and analyzing just how complex and carefully constructed this work is. The original is a very difficult read; this truly brings it all to life! "

" I was expecting history and got literary criticism. An excellent book if you want to learn about the Iliad and why it's such an important work, but not nearly as much history as I was looking for. Writing is good and it's a very thorough analysis of the Iliad. (Joy's review) "

" I read this for a book discussion; it's not something I'd have picked up. Doubtless it was a better book than I appreciated, so I'm giving it one more star than I was inclined to. "