" I'm really astounded how many people have read this book and taken it on face value. The most elementary google search reveals the guy as an irresponsible, ethically bankrupt, criminal fraud with no medical qualifications. Eating a teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda a day would give you the PH balance suggested by this book. The rest - eat healthhy - is a no brainer. The real blinding obvious fact is when you read it, he draws entirely unfounded and unscientific conclusions from things: Some people get sicker than others when exposed to airborne bacteria/viruses. Really? It's called genetics, some people are born with better immune systems than others. The same way some people are born with better teeth, bigger boobs, faster legs etc. It has very little to do with diet. Proof? The author's example is that in a plague some people in houses get sick and others don't - he puts this down to the acidity of diet. In 1918 (the period he cites) the majority of families would be eating the same diet within the family. So how can diet explain why a mother died and a father didn't, one child and not another? Please be more responsible about your beliefs people. You have access to information without precedent in history, so use it to verify things. We owe the future of our planet and humanity better than to abdure our own critical thinking to follow one manipulative guru then another.
On the subject of these types of books and claims there is a very simple strategy used by authors. It hooks in to the Protestant work ethic, Catholic guilt or any other type of religious morality. Does the author ask you to do something for your health, follow some regimen - that you are likely to either fail at or do imperfectly? If so can you see how the trick is played on you? It becomes your fault the technique didn't work, you internalize the failure of the technique. Let's compare this to non-quack medicine. Antibiotics, yes they are overused and yes incorrect use has enormous repercussions BUT they work. If you miss a dose here and there or stop taking it too early you will notice that whatever bacteria it was prescribed for has been beaten down or eliminated, you'll also have thrush or other types of problems associated with absence of good bacteria. The stuff kills bacteria, there's the proof. If you exercise but then you don't for a period you'll see the difference. Miracle diets/medicines don't make equivocal claims, it's either all or nothing you cure the cancer or you don't, you feel AMAZING or you feel tired. If you don't get the good results it's because you didn't follow the extreme regimen properly. The science shows simply taking baking soda daily would achieve the PH balance this quack recommends for ALL HEALTH issues, yet that would be easy for anyone to do as a regimen. Problem is when everyone who buys your book can do that the numbers will add up and people will realize the claim is bullshit. Keep your regimen improbable and esoteric and then the people buying your book will internalize the failure rather than realizing the fraudulent claims. Hell they'll go right on to another miracle cure, hoping they won't FAIL at this one too. "
— Sirosis, 2/9/2014