" I didn't like this book as much as I wanted to. I loved the title for a long time and I finally got around to reading it. I like part of the book very much. Philip's angst about what to do with his life, his feeling emotionally and socially crippled because of his own exaggerated deformity, and his intelligence that isn't serving him well, are all relatable. But all of the surrounding characters are unlikeable. It is not until the end of the book when he meets the Athleney family that some side characters can really be appreciated. I felt that Maugham was striving for realism but instead created a maudlin parody of it. The novel's strong points will stay with me, especially the wonderful existential philosophizing Philip does toward the end of the book. The epiphany only temporarily comforts him, but it does set the stage for him to finally be moving in a direction. He spent his youth moving from one thing to another and torturing himself with an unrequited love. It is one of the only books I have read where I don't want the love to be requited. Mildred is just a bad person. Philip's ability to be compassionate and self-sacrificing after the three ways she betrays him is neither a testament to love or a noble trait. It is acting out the self-destructive tendency that grew in him when he went to school and was made fun of for the club foot. I suppose I can recommend the book, but it just wasn't what I thought it would be. "
— Caitlin, 2/19/2014