" I'll admit right up front that this was not my favorite of the D'Artagnan Romances. As a "hard core" fan of the Four Inseparables, I wished there was more of them in this book. All the court intrigue in this one, while amusing, got a little tiring and tedious, especially since there were complicated love triangles and such--not my kind of thing. I also got sick and tired of Louise. I never minded her in any of the other books, and I loved her and Raoul, but what she did to him was heartless, and she made me angry for that, so I no longer have any respect for her character. Montalais, on the other hand, who I didn't like to begin with, I found a liked more and more as the story went on. She was a fun character and her coupled with Malicorn made for amusing situations. Dumas certainly can craft brilliant characters, that is for certain. And I did very much enjoy the parts that you did get to see the four friends, though they went too quickly for me. It was so refreshing to see Aramis still up to his shady deeds, Porthos being himself, and D'Artagnan still trying to keep up with everything though he's sick of palace life. I wished there was more of Athos as he is my favorite character next to D'Artagnan.
In short, this was not a bad read, and I would definitely recommend reading it to further your knowledge of events before reading Man in the Iron Mask. That one looks like it has better prospects and I am excited to get to it! "
— Hazel, 2/2/2014