" So this is kind of like Moby Dick. Except people travel with trains on the railsea instead of with boats on the ocean. Oh and giant mutant desert animals attack anyone who touches the dirt. So, better. There's also some nods to other nautical tales like the Odyssey, Treasure Island, and Robinson Crusoe. It was also slightly reminiscent of Iron Council, one of Mieville's Bas-Lag books with a heavy emphasis on trains. And even though it's labeled as a young adult book, it doesn't feel like it at all. Which is nice because I'm pretty sick of YA right now. The characters are all pretty interesting, I particularly liked the Captain and Sirocco, and the plot is entertaining. The weird narrator interjection chapters were kind of odd at first, but once I got used to them weren't bad. Overall this was definitely the kind of awesome that I expect from Mieville. "
— Jordan, 2/13/2014