" I am glad to see that I"m not the only one who struggled through this book, and who thought it was horrible. I have such fond memories of watching the movie as a child though I had never read the book. I saw this book in the annual book sale which I volunteer at, and thankfully got it free, because it was one of the worst and most boring books I've ever read. There are no great adventures, it's all about their every day life and the killings of animals (mostly for food and clothing, other times senseless). I skimmed through most of the words, most of the pages, most of the book as I didn't care to read every, and I mean every detail as how they cut apart the animal, how they made this, that etc. There was no need for such details. Even skimming through it took me a week to read this book - ahhh! How does one island have such a variety of animals is beyond me? How about all the different types of vegetation? How do the boys never fight? How do the parents never fight? Six people alone for 10 years and not one fight. Don't they drive each other crazy? It wasn't until the end that the father talked about how it would be nice to see other people. Doesn't the wife/mother long for woman company? All she ever does is garden and cook and then there's never any detail about her jobs. She never seemed to have a voice. I found the father rude to his wife, to his boys. How is the father so knowledgeable on every single type of animal and every single type of greenery. Done done done - yeah!!!!!!! "
— Shelley, 1/31/2014