" This book was about a time period I was quite unfamiliar with, which is part of the reason I picked it in the first place. I do feel that the atmosphere was authentic, and the characters intrigued me, but I couldn't help feeling that some things ended rather abruptly, or came up and then were dropped with little development. My favourite parts were the beginning and the end, which are narrated not in the past but in the present, by a teenage boy who is hearing the story from the elder Tilly herself. A note I have that relates not to the print version but to the audio version is how much I enjoyed and appreciated the talents of the respective narrators! They were easy to listen to, evoked a good mood, and made for a wonderful listening experience. "
— Victoria-Lynn, 12/19/2013