The Hour I First Believed: A Novel Audiobook

" I couldn't finish this book. Chapter 4 and I was as lost as two polar bears in a snow storm. "

" I'll preface this by saying that I LOVE Wally Lamb. I Know This Much is True and She's Come Undone are two of the best books I've ever read. I wanted to love this book, I really, really did and three stars might be a bit generous. It was a difficult book to get through. I don't mind that there were some tough issues covered in the book and I don't mind reading about them. It just felt disjointed, I didn't care about the characters (there were several points where I downright hated both of the main characters -- Caelum and Maureen, Maureen especially -- and honestly didn't care what happened to them). I was disappointed. Hopefully Lamb's next novel will be much more enjoyable to read. "

" This is about Columbine. I just couldn't get into it and actually stopped reading it. Just too depressing a topic and way off topic sometimes for me. I am really suprised because I loved some of Wally Lamb's other books, but the last two I read were bombs. "

" This book tells another side of the story the effects of a shooting. I love Wally Lamb's writing his stories keep me reading all night long. "

" It was good but ... "

" After falling in love with his previous novels, I could not even finish this book. Was very disappointed and would not recommend. "

" I loved this book - a work of fiction mingled with the true event details of the Columbine shootings. Anything Wally Lamb writes is a hit. I love that he doesn't pump out the novels, he takes his time and spins the most intricate and interesting tales. "

" I think that Wally Lamb is one of the most amazing contemporary writers of our time. As much as I wanted to love this book, I just couldn't. This book was just too long. It was as if Lamb and two great idea for two separate books, but squished it all together into one instead. I found that I just didn't want to read it anymore and had to force myself to get to the end. Very disappointing. "

" Was a good book, but very long and hard to follow. Starts out great and somehow winds around to nothingness. The first half is very hard to read about Columbine but very good. "

" This was a good story, but it was a little drawn out. There were dialogues that were repeated to the point where U thought that I lost my place. I listened to the audio version and it was 20 CD's. I think thagt it could have b een around 15. "

" listening to it.. couldn't get through the first disk. "

" I thought I'd hate this book. I didn't want to read about Columbine. But there was so much more to it, and, in the end, I enjoyed it. "

" Good book, plenty of twists. A little long winded at times. "

" This book is terrible. Strong start, but endless rambling, confusing tangents and disconnected plot lines just made me frustrated. I can't believe I finished it. Ugh. "

" I love this guy's writing and have since his first book. This one is particularly dense in plot...almost enough to make me sit it down. Almost! Very sad but uplifting in the end. "

" What a disappointment - after She's Come Undone and I Know This Much Is True could not wait for Wally Lamb's next novel and After reading this one I did come undone from BOREDOM!! "

" I found the meshing of the two stories, his wife's breakdown and his search into his own family history, awkward. I also question the using of real people in a work of fiction, although the author defends his reason for doing so. "

" Great book but sooooo many different story lines that at times it was hard to read "

" LOVE LOVE LOVE Wally Lamb. Please publish something soon! "

" Slow start, but loved the book "

" Like many others, this book was a huge let down. Very slow. Very depressing. Very blah. I always finish the books I start, but after 2 weeks of forcing myself to keep reading, I finally raised my white flag and surrendered. I just couldn't take one more page. "

" It took me a few times to get into this book but then I couldn't put it down. Parts of it grabbed my attention and other parts were all over the place or drawn out. Worth the read but other Wally Lamb books were better in my opinion. "

" One of my all time favorites. "

" Of the three Wally Lamb books I have read, this is my least favorite. It took me several months to read it and almost forgot about finishing it. However, the book takes a turn and the ending is beautiful. :) "

" Columbine? The Civil War? Mark Twain? Mythology? And Tesla? Yup~it is all here! <3 "

" This is one of Linda Corcoran's favorite authors. I am not as crazy about him. I did like this - alot going on - Columbine and a lot of trauma. "

" This was not as good as I thought it would be...I loved She's Come Undone, and there are parts of this book I loved, but overall it was quite disturbing and somewhat hard to get through at times. And WAY too long. "

" Very very depressing and dark - so be prepared for that - but overall I thought it was a very good book. The characters are interesting and they story is gripping... "

" The minute to monuite reenactment of the massacre was rivieting! "

" I thought it was an interesting read with a lot of side stories happening and the author even refers to characters in his previous books. "

" I waited patiently for 10 years for another Lamb novel. I devoured it and loved it. I sobbed and sobbed the last 1/4 of the book. Amazing. Thank you, Wally Lamb. "

" Many stories in one book. I loved it. It was a mixture of facts and fiction. "

" Very well-written, but like 3 REALLY depressing novels in one. Just a warning. "