" Interesting history of the oyster in America that was entertaining but at times too concerned with US history. Many parts of the book--especially within part 1--read as if the author was writing a history of New York and would merely sprinkle references about oysters that fit the time period he was discussing. That is not true for the entirety of part 1, but there are many instances where Kurlansky delves into US history so much that he neglects the oyster. Part 2, on the other hand, was very precise and focused, really giving you the sense of the oyster's place in America from colonial times to the present. I would give it an additional half-star if able. "
— Ruben, 2/15/2014