" This book is about the brain and many of its aspects, e.g. how it might work. The book also deals with "savants" and is written by one. Having seen documentaries on the phenomenon the book did not offer much new for me. As someone with a computer science education one thing that I noticed was a bit of a bias "against" CS. Even savants don't know how their brain works and I find it slightly presumptuous to reject the idea that AI is impossible and CS cannot produce "intelligent machines". I particularly take issue with describing computer sciences' language as "impoverished" and limiting it to storage, input, output and retrieval (quote in the book by Gerald Edelman). You don't have to belief in the "new age messengers" of AI like Mr. Kurzweil, but I had wished for more respect for an important scientific discipline. Final note: I found several typos in the book - you would think that especially in a book such as this the text would be flawless... But then again, we're all humans and no machines (yet)... "
— Jan, 2/15/2014