" SO LOVELY. The illustrations are overwhelming beautiful (something anyone who looks at Muth's work is used to), but this time they're also funnier (the running jack-o-lanterns and actual floating ghosts mixed in amongst the scene of kids trick-or-treating makes you take at least a second look at the pages to try to decide what's real and what isn't). The story feels a bit abrupt, and I don't LOVE that I get more explanation from the afterword than I do from the story itself (or from Stillwater), but I do understand why that is. Ghost stories are abrupt, and the koan here wouldn't be a true koan if you added on explanation. You're supposed to go with your gut reaction. "
— nicole, 1/15/2014