" This is the first Schmidt I've read. I feel not quite smart because I wasn't crazy about it; there were definitely things I liked about this book, and things I think were done well (all the family interactions, in particular), but overall it felt heavy handed and often obvious. I disliked the ending scenes--I was freaking out on a medical level, and I also don't know how they could DO that to their parents after everything else, which made me grumpy about characterizations. I don't have any problem with the subject matter being suitable for the Newbery, but have a hard time believing kids 14 and under would be very interested--and while the Newbery isn't for popularity etc, I don't think one could really call a book "distinguished writing for children" if children aren't interested, even after being urged/assigned; but I could be totally wrong about that, because, as you all know, I do not like books about boys, or dogs, and especially not about boys AND dogs. "
— Wendy, 1/30/2014