-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" O'Brian can be difficult to read but is wonderful to listen to when read by narrators like Patrick Tull. The language is sumptuous and period-perfect. Moreover, the author's mastery of details of the British Navy circa 1803 is unmatched. "
- Yovo, 10/23/2019
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" This entry in the series did not do much for me. Not much action throughout. "
- Stan, 2/14/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" #15 in the series. This book was another good addition to this long series of sea stories. "
- Sandy, 2/13/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Too much Clarissa and not enough... Well, not enough anything else really. "
- Robyn, 2/12/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" We "read" this audio book on a recent trip. It makes a good companion on the road, with the usual cast of characters. THis story is not too compelling, though, as Aubrey and the crew sail to one of the Sandwich Islands to take sides in a local dispute and keep the island for Britain. The "Surprise" is now operating as a privateer with a letter of marque, and not a royal navy vessel. THe real story is about a woman, with a mysterious past, sneaked aboard by a junior officer, and her effect on the crew. "
- Jrobertus, 2/7/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Overall, I am a huge fan of the series in general and O'Brian's writing in particular. His style is wonderful--there is hardly a better master of subtle and super-subtle irony going. But with this and the previous entry in the series, I feel as if the energy is flagging a little bit. As he has done several times in the past, O'Brian turns to ringing subtle changes on characters we have met previously by introducing new characters that chime with them in interesting ways. Enter Clarissa Oakes. Except that this time the new character seems to be a much more pallid version of Diana Villiers and Louisa Wogan. Naturally, she becomes the means for Maturin to ferret out (perhaps) the last of the nest of spies that has been a major part of the story arc for the previous six or seven novels. As interesting as parts of this several novel south seas interlude has been, I am eager to see O'Brian bring the series back to Europe and to the main sphere of action. Of course there are difficulties with that, since in the time frame he is working with, the British Navy has little to offer a ship of the line captain (such as Aubrey) except blockade duty. Here's hoping O'Brian racked his brains and came up with an interesting solution to these problems in the series' final quarter and returns the focus in some ways to the interactions between Aubrey and Maturin. On a different note (and I can't remember if I have remarked on this before--here's hoping that if I did, I write about differently this time), it is endlessly fascinating to see how O'Brian starts each of these novels off with a unique précis that doesn't repeat all the other little summaries he has given, just in case there is some reader out there who picked up the series in the middle. "
- Nelson, 2/6/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Wow, these books really seem to be slowing down. There was next to no action in this book at all. I had a really hard time getting through it. There was so much going on in the ship that was just hinted at here and there so you never really get a clear picture of what is really happening - and I'm not sure that I want to know some of the details. As seems to happen a lot with these books, the main action happens in the last 10 pages or so which makes you then want to continue on with the series to see what happens next. "
- Steph, 2/3/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The entire series is amazing. O'Brian's writing is a delight to read and while I could quibble over 4.5 stars or 5 per each volume I'm rating it across their totality. "
- Dan, 2/1/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" I love the all Aubrey-Maturin novels and this one was great, too. "
- Michael, 1/29/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Builds on the previous 14 books in the Aubrey-Maturin series "
- Paul, 1/29/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Dammit, another non-ending. I guess my marathon continues... "
- Ken-ichi, 1/23/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Good stuff, lots of words to look up. "
- Squeaky, 1/23/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" One of the shorter novels is the series, and looking back, one where surprisingly little happens. That is to say, there is only a gradual change in setting, and little tumultuous action. O'Brian uses this longer voyage to segway into a social experiment of the effect of women (a woman) in an environment normally totally devoid of their presence. The result is a some beautiful character development and fascinating conversation about the nature of relationships, conversation & communication, and general society. "
- Cole, 1/20/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Please finish them all, for all love! "
- Kathryn, 1/19/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" another great book in the series "
- Williamfry44, 1/18/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" another great book in the series "
- Williamfry44, 1/15/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Audiobook version, narrated by Simon Vance. "
- Karen, 1/8/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Don't like O'Brian's prose. He is a good writer, just not my style. I may finish the book sometime in the future. "
- Edward, 1/7/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The worst book of the series. "
- John, 1/7/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" If you read Patrick O'Brian, I suggest you start from the beginning with Master and Commander. The books make more sense if you follow the history of the series "
- Timothy, 1/7/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The Pacific Ocean Islands beckon for Captain Jack Aubrey and ship's surgeon and spy Stephen Maturin, together with thrilling adventures at sea. The equilibrium of shipboard life is unbalanced and Stephen receives valuable intelligence from an unexpected source. "
- JoTownhead, 1/1/2014
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Entitled "Clarissa Oakes" in the UK "
- Martin, 12/31/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" I think it's because yet again there was a woman on board but I really liked this one. I also liked Emily and Sarah and how they had different dialects for different parts of the ship. "
- Courtney, 12/6/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Patrick O'Brian wrote with such color and detail about this period that I am always captivated. This is one of my favorites of the Aubrey/Maturin series as it shows how the ship's company can be effected by a female presence on board. Loved it. "
- Susan, 11/29/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" One of my favorites so far in this series. Martin and Maturin's adventures in Australia had me laughing out loud, and the clever interweaving of the bits of plot surrounding Clarissa, Padeen, Maturin and his intrigues were perfect. "
- Isis, 11/14/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" This one is another that dips just slightly in the pace of the story, though there are some very important pieces of the overall arc introduced here. "
- J.E., 10/18/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Another great episode of the Aubrey-Maturin series. This is my 10th time through the series, and it keeps getting better. A lot to unwrap in this one. Audible edition, read by Patrick Tull. "
- Brian, 10/14/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Another entertaining story from O'Brian. Wonderfully descriptive and engaging throughout. "
- Mark, 10/8/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" More adventures for Captain Jack Aubrey and his good friend Stephen Maturin. I've already started the next book so particulars about this one are fading. I'm still enjoying the series and I think I need to watch Master and Commander again now that I know most of the characters pretty well. "
- ghostlibrarian, 9/30/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" If you read Patrick O'Brian, I suggest you start from the beginning with Master and Commander. The books make more sense if you follow the history of the series "
- Timothy, 9/27/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Still working my way through the Patrick O'Brian series, and this book is a fine addition the the group. Not my favorite, although I'd be hard pressed to pick a favorite, but enjoyable nonetheless. "
- Andrea, 5/4/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" I think it's because yet again there was a woman on board but I really liked this one. I also liked Emily and Sarah and how they had different dialects for different parts of the ship. "
- Courtney, 4/19/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The entire series is amazing. O'Brian's writing is a delight to read and while I could quibble over 4.5 stars or 5 per each volume I'm rating it across their totality. "
- Dan, 4/8/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" So far, my least favorite. Nothing new or exciting. Must have been during a dry spell or for money. "
- Theron, 2/16/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" This one is another that dips just slightly in the pace of the story, though there are some very important pieces of the overall arc introduced here. "
- J.E., 1/9/2013
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Previously read in mid-2008, again in May 2009. Aubrey and Maturin sail from Sydney to Moahu. Intrigue involving Clarissa Oakes. "
- Greg, 10/2/2012
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Part of a series of seafaring historical novels. Not much plot, but certainly a primer on 18th (19th?) century seamanship. "
- Enid, 9/1/2012
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The worst book of the series. "
- John, 6/26/2012
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" #15 in the series. This book was another good addition to this long series of sea stories. "
- Sandy, 3/23/2012
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Please finish them all, for all love! "
- Kathryn, 2/17/2012
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Not nearly as good in my opinion as the other books in the series to date. This novel was light on plot and seemed to be more of a place holder than anything else. "
- Tagg, 12/4/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" One of my favorites so far in this series. Martin and Maturin's adventures in Australia had me laughing out loud, and the clever interweaving of the bits of plot surrounding Clarissa, Padeen, Maturin and his intrigues were perfect. "
- Isis, 10/17/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Too much Clarissa and not enough... Well, not enough anything else really. "
- Robyn, 9/28/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Don't like O'Brian's prose. He is a good writer, just not my style. I may finish the book sometime in the future. "
- Edward, 8/11/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" So far, my least favorite. Nothing new or exciting. Must have been during a dry spell or for money. "
- Theron, 8/11/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Previously read in mid-2008, again in May 2009. Aubrey and Maturin sail from Sydney to Moahu. Intrigue involving Clarissa Oakes. "
- Greg, 6/22/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Interesting details on sailing ships. Odd focus on a female stowaway. "
- Paul, 6/4/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" The Pacific Ocean Islands beckon for Captain Jack Aubrey and ship's surgeon and spy Stephen Maturin, together with thrilling adventures at sea. The equilibrium of shipboard life is unbalanced and Stephen receives valuable intelligence from an unexpected source. "
- JoTownhead, 5/29/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Good stuff, lots of words to look up. "
- Squeaky, 4/6/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Previously read in mid-2008.
"
- Greg, 3/19/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Only five left! What ever will I do when I finish them? Start them all again of course.
"
- Booksthailand, 3/8/2011
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Please finish them all, for all love!
"
- Kathryn, 12/4/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" This one is another that dips just slightly in the pace of the story, though there are some very important pieces of the overall arc introduced here.
"
- J.E., 11/29/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" #15 in the series. This book was another good addition to this long series of sea stories.
"
- Sandy, 9/16/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Dammit, another non-ending. I guess my marathon continues...
"
- Ken-ichi, 8/19/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" One young woman can cause a lot of trouble on a ship full of men.
This book started off slowly, but soon it went along as his books usually do. Patrick O'Brian was apparently a keen observer of human nature. His depiction of characters' actions and reactions is simply exquisite.
"
- Jocelyn, 7/6/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" Builds on the previous 14 books in the Aubrey-Maturin series
"
- Paul, 3/13/2010
-
Overall Performance:




Narration Rating:




Story Rating:




" One of my favorites so far in this series. Martin and Maturin's adventures in Australia had me laughing out loud, and the clever interweaving of the bits of plot surrounding Clarissa, Padeen, Maturin and his intrigues were perfect.
"
- Isis, 1/17/2010
> Hide All