" A frustrating book that I wanted to be better than it was. On the one hand, the central characters--Bartholomew the thin man, Matina the fat lady, and Alley the strongman--are well drawn, and Ms. Bryson clearly did her research in regards to Barnum's museum and the lives of circus freaks. On the other hand, the novel revolves around two big "A-ha" moments that are telegraphed from halfway through, making the novel's resolution feel like an anticlimax. It was a fairly compelling read, but it wasn't the type of novel that makes me say "I've got to read her next book." "
— Chris, 1/21/2014