The Singing: The Fourth Book of Pellinor Audiobook

" All in all, I liked the Pellinor saga, but as already mentioned about the first three books, the series would have needed a good lector to make it a really good one. The end now was somehow dummy, I expected more than just travelling with a few obstacles to a certain place and playing mostly unhampered a song. "

" Ok working on a review. :) "

" The last book in the series reunites all of the major players for the much awaited Singing. But, something was missing -- it fell short of the wonderful story of the first book. Maerad and Cadvan were a bit estranged, and everyone seemed tired of the whole journey. "

" I liked this series. This book was a good ending to it. It's not my favorite by any means but as a series for young readers it's very entertaining. "

" I loved pretty much every bit of this story. It tied up every thread and brought the storylines of Hem and Maerad back together. As with every good YA story, good triumphs in the end. You couldn't ask for more than that. At least, I couldn't. :) "

" What a fabulous ending to a fabulous series! I highly recommend this. "

" That was basically a throwaway. Extremely disappointing. "

" The whole series was fantastic. A blend of Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings the world created and described by Alison Croggon was realistic and magical all at the same time. "

" A fitting conclusion to a darn good series. Does not dissapoint! "

" A well-concluded end to the series. I would say that it was a wee bit anti-climatic after the build up of the previous books, but overall I was very happy with the series. Good, ol' fashioned reading. "

" i have not read it yet, but it will be AMAZING! "

" A wonderful end to the series! I enjoyed getting to read about both Hem and Maerad's tales, and ended the book more than satisfied... and sad that the series is over. "

" Good end to this young adult fantasy series. "

" I definatly liked the previous three much more. I found the way the author chose to end the series abrupt and unsatisfying, but otherwise really liked this series. "

" Such a great ending. I even wanted another book, but it was still a good ending. I felt satisfied. "

" I was highly surprised at most of the events in this story. It was most intruiging and amazing! "

" Sub par, predictable ending...to such an extent that I withdraw my previous notions - it is no longer considered 'epic' on my bookshelves. "

" Excellent! I just loved this series. I'm so sad that's it's over. "

" I really like this book, though, I'm a little disappointed at the ending. "

" I really tried to give this series a chance. I bought all the books and tried to slog through but I have even giving this book a star. I wish the option existed of giving it fewer. Nothing here at all really worth anyone's time. I wasted my time. "

" I enjoyed this series a lot. I listened to it so the readers made a big difference. A lot of fun for those who like fantasy work. "

" Brilliant conclusion to the Bardic Tale. I know that all four books are young adult section; however, the vocabulary and the richness of content were on par with the best I have read. "

" It's so nice to read a series where the fourth book is every bit as good as the first! What a wonderful series. "

" 3.5 stars. Slightly disappointing climax, not enough resolution between the two main characters. "

" The rating i'm giving it would be what I would rate the 4-book series as a whole. It was entertaining, but it could have been better. "

" glad to finally be done with this series. a nice conclusion, though done a little too hastily. while Croggon has a tendency to over-detail every bit of landscape, she was completely under-detailed in the development of the relationships/romances/final resolution. "

" I loved pretty much every bit of this story. It tied up every thread and brought the storylines of Hem and Maerad back together. As with every good YA story, good triumphs in the end. You couldn't ask for more than that. At least, I couldn't. :) "

" It was a lot of reading to get through this series, but I am sad that it is over. I enjoyed the books enough to check out the author's website and other works. Great reading. "

" I liked the ending and really enjoyed reading this series. Alison Croggon is a good writer. "

" This book followed the story of Hem, Maerad's younger brother. Even though the point of view changed it was still a well written and enjoyable read. It followed the story line of the first two books perfectly. "