The Red Garden Audiobook

" This was good- it was neat to see all the stories entwined. (And FYI Towards the end language/incidents get kind of rough.) "

" I would probably give this book a 7 on a scale of 1-10. I am not a fan of short stories, but the connection between these made it definitely worthwhile. I liked the sense of place that came thru; could have even been more in my opinion. But overall a good read. "

" I have been a reader of her books since she started writing. She always weaves a magical element into her books. This one traced the history of a town and it's people. A little quirky, fun and sometimes sad. In some places it felt a little dis-jointed. I would have loved to have seen a family tree at the end of the book. "

" First off: this is a collection of short stories that intertwine: confusing but in the end WHAM...very cool. "

" This was a great book. It is sort of a series of short stories, all happening in the same place, but with different characters through out time. And yet, it was a book I didn't want to put down. "

" Alice Hoffman weaves a tale of middle Massachusetts from Colonial days referencing history and folklore such as the Deerfield attacks and Johnny Appleseed to present. Her characters flow through time and their stories are all intertwined. The chapters are like short stories. Some I liked better than others. "

" Excellent assortment of stories connected by their setting. Each story was interesting and held my attention. I was left wanting more. Alice Hoffman is magical. "

" Had high hopes for this one, but could not get interested in it. May try again later. "

" it was okay. although I enjoyed the magical realism style and most of the stories, I felt it was a long way to go for a medicore ending. I also constantly wished for a family tree illustration. "

" I was disappointed in this book. Just about the time you got to know a character, the story jumped ahead a generation or two. It just seemed like a parade of odd characters. "

" I've never read any of Hoffman's work before. I won't bother again. Linked personal histories in a Western Massachusetts town from the 1700's to the present; each chapter being a different era. "

" Hoffman has such a wonderful talent for spinning a tale through generations. "

" Alice Hoffman has never been in my repertoire of books, but after reading The Red Garden, I'm looking forward to more of her writing. I particularly liked the layering of successive generations in the same place. "

" Listened to the audio book version -- absorbing and moving tales. Kinda wish a few were a little less tragic...but there you have it. "

" Alice Hoffman never fails to tell an twisting story of relationships. Here an entire town emerges in history and works its way generation by generation to the present through the residents. "

" Not at all what I was expecting. It read like a series of short stories, which I'm not a huge fan of. Plus I could not keep the characters straight from timeframe to timeframe. But some of the individual chapters were good. I just like a bit more dialog in my books, so this one was tough for me. "

" I wasn't expecting to like this book as much as I did... a surprise unfolded at the turn of every page. Her prose is something special. I was lost in the world of so many different vivid characters. clever. "

" Stories about requitted and unrequitted love with unusual characters and twists. "

" Hard for me to get into at first but once I started I couldn't put it down. Interesting way it was written and connecting the history of the town and the people. But didn't really have an ending I guess. Different book & a pretty good one. "

" I am a big fan of Alice Hoffman. I have read all of her books. This was not one of her best. "

" was alittle fragmented but i have come to love her books.. anxious to start another "

" A story of the lives of characters in Blackwell. While it held my interest there was something less than real about these folks. "

" Really liked this one. Thought about the characters long after their chapters were over. "

" A series of related stories about a Massachusetts town and its founders. I really liked the differences among the lead characters; each one was distinct. "

" Not nearly as strong as the author's "The Dovekeepers," but still a good read. "

" I have yet to be disappointed with a book by Alice Hoffman. I kept wanting to read this book to find out what was coming next. I liked how she linked all the people in the stories together. Would highly recommend! "

" Although these are short stories, they all happen in this one town, to this one family. A beautiful book. "

" How can you go wrong with black eels and black bears? "

" I loved this book - the intertwining history of the women - kept me thinking "

" Almost as good as Hoffman's "Blackbird House." Think magical realism as the genre. "

" I really liked this book. I wanted to hear more stories about the people of Blackwell. This book also inspired me to get together with my grandparents and document their history, stories, and family tree. I am really interested in family history. "

" Hmmm what to say??? Seemed disconnected? No real story not very interesting. Lost interest. "

" Wow, I loved reading this book. I enjoyed the stories that passed through many generations all in the same town. Alic Hoffman, you are an amazing writer. "

" I'm not a fan of short stories, and this book had that flavor. Much like her previous book, The Blackbird House, an inanimate object was the main character, with humans and animals playing supporting roles. Of all the Alice Hoffman books I have read, this is probably my least favorite. "

" The Red Garden was hard to start but eventually each chapter is its own story, linked together by characters and progressing in years...pretty good concept. "

" It's rare for me to say I just 'liked it' about an Alice Hoffman book.But the episodic nature of this book with little compelling as an overarcing story made it an oddly unaffecting read. "

" Each chapter builds on previous characters and their family from years past. It starts with 3 couples leaving a large city to "Go West". "

" Typical Alice except as short stories. "

" Beautiful. Haunting. Redemptive. Another Alice Hoffman book I'll highly recommend. "

" short stories as novel, history of decades, lifetime spans, living and the dead, ghost girl, bear lovers, mystery gardens, Alice Hoffman at her magical weave again, terrific. "