" This was the easiest Hardy book to get into -- the main characters were clearly introduced and the storyline was set up in a more straightforward fashion than I've seen in other Hardy books. So I began by really enjoying this book, because for once I felt like I had some idea of where it was going from the start ... but as the book continued, I realized that Hardy actually set up the story TOO much, to the point that it became extremely predictable. In particular, Hardy tended to present a happy occurrence only in order to utterly reverse people's fortunes a couple pages later. These were not set-ups that had been carefully and subtly developed throughout the story, but rather quick jobs inserted directly before the tragedy that Hardy wanted to create -- and he played this little game several times too many for it to be a novelty or surprise when bad things happened. In the end, I was disappointed by the book that had begun so interestingly and ended so predictably. "
— Ilona, 12/30/2013