" Having grown up in the Pasadena area, and moving back here as an adult, I enjoyed reading this book purely for the fact that Mr. Ebershoff did an impressive job of weaving together much of Pasadena's history. Unfortunately, that can not be said for the story or for the characters. The story within a story with Bruder pouring his secrets out to Mr. Blackwood was simply not believable. Mr. Ebershoff wants to create a history that is akin to East of Eden, but sadly, Great American Novel material, this is not. "
— Judy, 2/16/2014