" kotlowitz illuminated many things about chicago history and politics, which i really appreciated, since it is all kinds of confusing for newcomers. and his profiles were funny and touching. however, the book felt uneven to me. or maybe unfocused? such a big subject. and even though his philosophy is that a city is the people in it, how do you choose among the many remarkable people in a city the size of chicago? i think this was the problem here. i found myself wondering why kotlowitz chose the people he did and what relationship they had to each other, other than being chicagoans. a narrower focus or a longer book of more in-depth profiles probably would of solved this. some of the profiles were just getting interesting when they ended, which made me mad. to paraphrase kenneth the page, i don't want to swear, but i am irritated right now. "
— Melisa, 1/28/2014