" This collection of stories posing as a novel had some problems. I don't know any seventh grade teacher who would teach To Kill a Mockingbird, This Boy's Life, or Romeo and Juliet. Ms. Hempel's argument "justifying" the language of the Wolfe autobiography would never cut the mustard with parents of my seventh graders. Also, Ms. Hempel is an English teacher, but it was obvious that Ms. Bynum could have used an English teacher to assist with grammar, at least to explain how to use colons properly. That being said, this novel did have its moments. I could identify with Ms. Hempel's gruesome daydream about breaking something that would require a full body cast and thus release her from her teaching career. There is some truth in her observation that teaching "had rendered her unfit for everything else." I have felt the deep tenderness she describes as I've watched students pour over yet another standardized test. Some of the observations are valid even if the character is a bit wonky. Bynum seems to me a writer in the vein of Lorrie Moore and Elizabeth McCracken. The generous critic believes her best work is yet to come. "
— Melinda, 1/31/2014