" This must be one ofhis best novels. The romance as it calls itself and it is a romance, reads well from beginning to end. Especially fascinating is his portrayal of Jews. On the one hand, Isaac is portrayed in the manner customary at the time, the connviing above all pusillanimous Jew, but his daughter Rebecca is the heroine of the novel, and Ivanhoe clearly loves her, but as Forster put it in Pasage to India the time and place forbade their union. A very interesting character is the Templar who is very "progressive" in his contempt for religion, which he calls superstition coupled with his adherence to the chivaric code which is ambiguous and his ambition which is not ambiguous, likewise his pride. King Richard Coeur de Lion is presented as a deeply flawed but still likable man. This novel is at once a good yarn but stimulating to thought and non dogmatic. I did wonder though, in the manner with which Scott is sympathetic to the Saxon cause but effectively shows that the fait acoimpli of Norman rule is indeed that accompli, promoting the idea that Jacobean romantics should accept the Hannovrian succession and the Union of Scotland and England. "
— Esdaile, 9/20/2013