" We use Phyllis Tickle's prayers for the daily office regularly in our household and I have enjoyed other of her books. But the Great Emergence: How Christianity is Changing and Why is a fairly horrible book. Oh, Tickle has a few winning observations, but they are hidden among over generalization, poorly assembled historical details, useless drawings and charts, and tiresome prose. Her claims are huge, her documentation and footnotes scanty. The idea that today's "Great Emergence" is part of a five hundred year recurring cycle in Christian history offers a chance to hasten through church history, when she might have been better advised to actually have a fuller argument for the present day. Do not trust her historical judgments - her "prophecies" about the future seem fairly dubious as well. "
— Tim, 1/20/2014