" One and a half of those stars are for the wonderful language that Cornish uses throughout the entire book- a special combination of archaic and made up vocabulary that is rather addictive, especially with the slight accent of the reader in the audio version. The half star is for having wonderful character but the lack of other stars is due to the author's neglect to actually do anything with, well, any of the characters. This results in the main deficiencies being plot oriented, but it's also close to impossible to have a meaningful theme without plot and the evolution of characters. There seems to be a bit of "camping" (a la Harry Potter #7) at the beginning where nothing happens, but then it turns out that Rossamund doesn't typically do anything anyway. In fact, he's all but left out of the climax which was not very climatic, as it didn't really involve the hero, except in a tacked-on sort of way, and didn't really resolve any of the hero's problems. It really needed a bigger story arch over the course of all three books and more action. Otherwise, the setting and character abilities are innovative and the language fun. "
— Erin, 1/30/2014