Earthfall: Homecoming: Volume 4 Audiobook

" Finally the family has left Harmony and travels to Earth! It took them long enough. This book continues the Homecoming Trilogy. Equally good. See my review of Memory of Earth. "

" Fun but the Book of Mormon did it better. "

" this one wasn't as good as the others. the sentient rats and bats seemed random. maybe i would have liked it more had i read it instead of listened. it just seemed more of the same with not much gained in the story line. "

" Not as good as the first three in the series. "

" There were things I really liked about this book, but I got extremely tired of having to read over and over Nafai's whining about how unworthy he was and how much he wanted his brother Elemak to love him back. Also, the fact that people were still saying Nafai was so young even when he obviously wasn't was asinine. I enjoyed the first three much more and hope that the last one isn't such a disappointment. "

" The third book started off great, but by the time I was knee deep in the book it was getting repetitive, and not branching out to knew obstacles. I was a little disappointed after reading the other books. "

" Not a bad book, but not a great one either. A badly disguised space adaptation of The Book of Mormon. "

" It was alright, interesting to see how he develops the story line. Ending wasn't as good as 2nd and 3rd book. Hopefully he will pull it all together for the 5th book. "

" I don't get the angels/diggers thing. "

" Cool new characters. Very creative but should probably be 100 pages shorter. "

" While I enjoyed the theory of the saga, I was tired by the time I reached this book. "

" Boo. Very boo. "

" Good book; nice to see the progress being made from Harmony to Earth. "

" Earthfall (Homecoming Saga) by Orson Scott Card (1996) "

" I mean, could this be any more of a blatant copy of the BOM? "

" Read half, not my cup of tea:( "

" This book was a marked improvement from the previous one, though still not that great. I do like how Orson Scott Card gets back into his niche of multiple sentient species occupying the same space on a planet. He does that pretty well. "

" A little better than the previous one. Not as good as the first. "

" The cover is comical. But I think this is my favorite of the series... "

" I actually disliked this book. "

" So disappointed. Card's interesting plots and engaging characterizations are lost as he attempts to draw too many religious parallels. I hated this series and I found this book to be the worst. "

" yeah, mr. orson scott, i see how you start getting tired of this series... you can feel it in your writing, no doubt, its preety amazing you wrote earthborn after this, because after this one, i was pretty bored myself... took too long to get to earth. "

" good until 4/5 through blatantly borrowing, qnd switching from character to escalating plot to bring a conclusion. "

" This one got a little confusing with the strange names and naming conventions, but overall it was an interesting story. "

" Good book; nice to see the progress being made from Harmony to Earth. "

" The 4th book leads us to Earth. We learn of the conflict between the angels and the diggers and how their lives are symbiotic. The two tribes of Earth become firmly divided between Nafai and Elemak. "

" Finished the 4th book in the series today. There were many aspects of this book that I liked more than in the other books. Looking forward to starting book 5 on my way home this evening~ "

" It was alright, interesting to see how he develops the story line. Ending wasn't as good as 2nd and 3rd book. Hopefully he will pull it all together for the 5th book. "

" This one got a little confusing with the strange names and naming conventions, but overall it was an interesting story. "

" October 13, 2007 October 16, 2007 "

" Earthfall (Homecoming Saga) by Orson Scott Card (1996) "

" The third book started off great, but by the time I was knee deep in the book it was getting repetitive, and not branching out to knew obstacles. I was a little disappointed after reading the other books. "

" It seemed like Card was in a hurry. It's not that he didn't have a good plot and great characters. It's more like he just didn't bother to take the detail to portray both to its greatest potential. Therefore, it is the stories of the previous books in the series that carry this story through. "

" While I enjoyed the theory of the saga, I was tired by the time I reached this book. "

" The cover is comical. But I think this is my favorite of the series... "