-




Sarah Black | 2/20/2014
" I adored this- brilliant "
-




Larry | 2/10/2014
" I always liked this author's work, but this book was really awful. "
-




Jeri | 1/29/2014
" Interesting; good descriptions; fascinating characters. However, with that said, I'm not sure whether I liked the book. It's the story of one man's "journey" in life, starting out as the son of two itinerant people who grows up to become a doctor almost despite them. It's his story of "practicing" in the same small town, accusations of assisted suicide, unrequited love and lust (which is requited) and then a calming ending....set in Montana, I enjoyed much of it because it referenced towns like Harlowtown (where my Dad grew up) and Two Dot, which I never believed existed until I met someone from there. The Montana mind-set and ruggedness certainly adds to the story. Will be anxious to have someone else's "take" on the book. "
-




Dave | 1/21/2014
" best mcguane in years. only mcguane fiction in years, but quite good. "
-




Bob | 1/19/2014
" This book is very hard to describe - a rambling story of a modern small town western doctor, and his search for meaning in the midst of the maelstrom of daily life. Too many disconnected pieces to make a comprehensible whole, but certainly an interesting perspective on modern American life. "
-




Ted | 1/11/2014
" I have been a big fan of Mr. McGuane for several decades and, once again, he instills a sense of place that is hard to beat. For much of the book, I was truly interested in the lives and antics of the characters. Unfortunately, as the story progressed, I came to see the characters as simple and flawed caricatures. So much so that I lost interest in them and their situations. "
-




Mark Myers | 1/7/2014
" An astonishing, satisfying writer. "
-




Laurie Twiehaus | 12/31/2013
" This is a good story from a man's point of view of his whole life, his parents, his decision to become a doctor and all his relationships. I enjoyed seeing how a man thinks about his interactions. "
-




Linda | 12/31/2013
" I cannot relate to big country, open spaces & small towns but this wonderful book gave me an insight that books like Easy of Eden did not. Berl is a rich complex character, a troubled man, a winner. It was funny, rambling and so nice to read. "
-




Ruth | 12/7/2013
" Pretty good book. A bit slow but overall quite pleasing. Not sure I would read this author again but not sorry I read this one. "
-




Jennifer | 12/3/2013
" A wonderful book if you're in the mood to enjoy the journey and appreciate the details. McGuane can knit words together that make you stop and marvel at their beauty, irreverence, insight. "
-




Robert Murray | 12/3/2013
" What a warm and comforting read to chase away a cold and blustery winter. "
-




Bob Peru | 11/19/2013
" the best novel he's done in years. i really like is short story collection "gallatin canyon" as well. "
-




Winnie Youngblood | 2/24/2013
" Didn't actually finish this - I almost never do that! "
-




Rick Muir | 11/11/2012
" Truly entertaining with remarkable and humorous insights on life. "
-




Cheryl | 6/23/2012
" This was my first McGuane book. While I really enjoyed some parts of this book there were times that I almost gave up out of boredom as it seemed to meander and go nowhere. In the end I was glad I stuck with it. I will definitely try something else by the author. "
-




Dede | 4/28/2012
" This was perfect to listen to as we drove 1200 miles from CO to CA. "
-




Molly | 2/12/2012
" Never managed to like any of the characters- most of them seemed like caricatures of quirky individuals. The story jumped around in a manner that made it hard to feel invested in what was happening. "
-




Chrissie | 4/27/2011
" Solid. Really funny one-liners. Just an oddball guy reminiscing about his oddball life.
"
-




Rick | 3/1/2011
" Truly entertaining with remarkable and humorous insights on life.
"
-




Vicky | 2/15/2011
" I think this is the first Tom Mcguane book I've read. I know he is a very popular author, but this story just didn't engage my interest. I'd be interested if any one else reads this what you think.
"
-




Robert | 2/8/2011
" What a warm and comforting read to chase away a cold and blustery winter.
"
-




Hillary | 2/7/2011
" This book is somewhat disjointed, with many underlying stories and no resolution. I'm not sure I like it now that I'm done, but I enjoyed hearing the stories while they lasted.
"
-




Bob | 1/9/2011
" the best novel he's done in years. i really like is short story collection "gallatin canyon" as well.
"
-




Molly | 12/29/2010
" Never managed to like any of the characters- most of them seemed like caricatures of quirky individuals. The story jumped around in a manner that made it hard to feel invested in what was happening.
"
> Hide All