" I pushed myself to read something high-brow with this book, although it was a birthday or Christmas gift to me. One mark against it - it uses 'prodigal' to mean going away and coming back. That's two books in a row. The main first-person character in this, Sinclair, lives a life of the mind - very mental. It was hard to get behind him as the book begins with him being bullied and he doesn't fight it - he just gives in and suffers. But instead of feeling low self-esteem, he goes the other way, and starts to feel superior to the rest of his family and most of humanity. And his friend Demian feeds his identity of being special ("the mark of Cain") with his alternate interpretations of what they learn in school together. And I can't see the average reader making much sense out of this book - and I didn't when I first read it in college. Now it's interesting historically as a rare book that uses references to the metaphysical writings of the day, dream interpretation, eastern philosophy, theosophy, White Magic, meditation, unconventional teacher/student relationships in a bare-bones story, set just before World War I. If you stay with it, Hesse does draw different elements of the story together in a "quickening" at the end, which is a relief, even though the book is fairly short. It just wasn't fun following such a self-absorbed character through an entire book. "
— Thom, 2/8/2014