" I picked this up based on a list of "best" historical mysteries in a recent Wall Street Journal. Yes, there is quite a bit of interesting historical information here, but it's pretty fragmentary -- if you're really interested in learning something about ancient Alexandria, read the excellent "The Rise and Fall of Alexandria". If you're interested in a good detective story, look elsewhere. This is a silly compilation of lame deaths and murders, supposedly unified around the pending nomination of a new Alexandria librarian, and laced with various facts and guesses about life in ancient Alexandria. Written in the first person, in a conversational modern style, from the point of view of the detective (improbably named Marcus Didius Falco) the whole exercise has a false ring to it. Don't bother. "
— Al, 2/15/2014