" Amish teen Eliza isn't sure she wants to embrace her lifestyle any longer. Given the opportunity to visit the "regular" world and be a nanny to two children for the summer, she finds the idea appealing and is thrilled when her parents finally consent. Her impressions of the big world are tediously described and the book could have used a better editing job (it is way too long, at almost 400 pages); there is little descriptive writing and the author never transports us. Characters are stereotyped and boring and the relationship that Eliza forms with the children she is caring for is hardly believable given the lack of storyline to support it. These things said, the basis for the story is interesting (the idea of all young Amish people having a rumspringa, or chance to see how the other half lives for a few months, as well as a look at modern day Amish, are two refreshing and little-addressed topics) and teens should find Eliza and her conflicts appealing...if they pick this tome up, in the first place,and manage to get through it. Junior high, high school. "
— Phoebe, 1/27/2014