" Not exactly sensational, but a solid story. It concentrates more on the trial than the murder and I think a little more suspense around that event would have juiced the tale up more. Still, the writing provides a vivid sense of pre-Civil War New York (with sinister Jack-the-Ripper-esque overtones) and the characters are engaging and intriguingly opaque. Plus, I am a sucker for fiction based on fact, and I think the author made a pretty admirable attempt at imagining a true historical event. "
— Caitlin, 2/4/2014