" I don't know that I was particularly excited to read this book, but I had felt that it was one of those books that you should read. Having now attained that goal, I can say that it wasn't a waste of time, even if it wasn't the most exciting use of my time either. Stephen Crane uses pretty stirring prose and realism in depicting the vagaries of war. His descriptions linger on images and ensure that you have a full idea of the physical setting and actions, and he speculates rather convincingly on the emotions and thought processes going on during battle, slicing out the romanticism of war, without completely annihilating its moments of nobility either. While that is his strength, it is also his weakness. His tone is so measured and deliberate, that the passion of war is eked right out of the pages. I think this is largely because of his decision to leave his protagonist mainly nameless (while his name may be Henry Flemming, we only learn this from other characters, never from the narrator, who only refers to him as "the youth"). I can understand why Crane chose to do this, because a character without a name could help the reader to place him or herself in that character's shoes ... this is an everyman character. But that is where Crane loses me. In his attempt to be universal in character, his wide span only hits the mark in a couple of different places. It is hard to force yourself into another character's shoes when you disagree with a lot of the things that they are doing or feeling, or if you simply cannot see yourself doing or feeling those same things. This universal approach also, as I mentioned, robs the passion from the war. If I were more invested in this character the defeats would be that much more harsh to accept, the victories, that much more glorious. As it was, I was almost indifferent to the character's outcome, because I was not connected to him. Ironically, as Crane showed the plight and purpose of the common soldier, it gave me the feeling of the uncaring officer as a spectator to the narrative.
Overall, however, Crane's work of realism cannot be discounted completely by his all-encompassing approach, and I would recommend anyone who would like an idea of the thoughts and feelings and horrors of a battle in action, to read this book. "
— Marty, 1/17/2014