" I'm torn between giving this book a 3 and a 4. I really liked how it was written, and some of the portrayals of place and character. But I just didn't buy the core premise. (view spoiler)[It simply seemed implausible, given the characters that the reader has come to know, that Erzsi would so utterly forsake Marika, XXX, and even Tamas -- who has done nothing wrong and seems to love her passionately -- because Marika turns out to be her stepmother (ish) rather than her mother. Really, getting upset -- I get that. Storming out and having NO contact for 12 years? Come on. And the entire book is centered around this premise -- it's the huge dramatic twist that Hall withholds from us for years and years of Erzski's life -- so when the premise falls flat, the entire book really suffers. (hide spoiler)] If the book had ended differently, and not tried to be Oh So Dramatic and with Such a Shocking Twist, I think I would have absolutely loved it. As it is -- well, I can't give it 3.5 stars, so I am settling for 3. "
— Marie, 1/19/2014