" This is my least favorite of the Circle books, though I still like it. Briar is one of my favorite of the characters (though Tris holds the top spot) and I love Evvy. But the gang stuff just doesn't do it for me, neither the initial assumption that gangs are good, nor the final decision that they are not (which felt a bit forced to me.) The other books in this second series about the Circle are mysteries, and I much preferred them. There is no mystery here, which is a disappointment. I still enjoyed the book, though, as I have enjoyed just about everything Tamora Pierce writes. "
— Ann, 1/31/2014