" Like many reviewers, I read Sea of Poppies, loved it, and waited with bated breath for the sequel. Alas, River of Smoke proved to be less satisfying. It has many of the same elements that I loved in Sea of Poppies -- the historical detail, the linguistic playfulness, the quirky yet believable characters (many of them new). However, it was missing the narrative drive and emotion that made SoP addictive. In SoP, the characters are on a metaphorical as well as physical journey, and grow and develop in surprising ways. In RoS, the only character with significant change is Bahram Moddie, and his story arc was a bit too predictable for me to become fully invested. Also disappointing was that Paulette, who was captivating in SoP, was relegated to a narrative device in RoS. Still, I plan to read the third installment, and would recommend both books to anyone who thinks globalization is a modern phenomenon. "
— Rachell, 2/7/2014