" I felt like Weir did a good job of trying to construct the most accurate picture of Mary by going back to contemporary sources and starting there. The problem, as she freely admits, is that there is not a lot of actual material on Mary's life, and only two of her letters survive. Based on the lack of actual information, Weir did a good job looking at the society and conditions of the time and try and make some inferences to fill in the blanks and dispel widely-accepted inaccuracies where she could. However, sometimes the assumptions she made felt too tenuous and Weir's pro-Mary bias came through very clearly in the writing. An interesting read purely for the fact since not many historical works solely focusing on Mary exist, but not completely satisfying for the above listed reasons. "
— Cheryl, 2/10/2014