" I will admit that I was not so in love with this play. It just isn't as good as part one, and though the final scene is definitely one of the most devastating not just in Shakespeare but in theater, it felt like a lot of the Hal/Falstaff relationship got ignored in the rest of the play to make room for drunk slapstick. And not that there's not a lot of good to be had in drunk slapstick, but with Hal not even showing up until Act 2 scene 2, it felt unfocused. After part 1, I think there was enough history for half a play, which meant that this play feels like it has a lot of filler. Also, since one of the play's major theme is aging and dying, it has a melancholy throughout that makes it not a fun read. Good, not my favorite. "
— Sara, 1/31/2014