" The writing is quite good, but it's not the kind that compensates for any lack in the story. I didn't like the story much, so at times this was a bit of a chore. It's about a man who is in love with a woman he knows is worthless and mean (Hamilton helpfully clarifies with authorly authority that she has no real consciousness and is a fish, not a human being) and has no affection for him, but hangs around her all the time anyway. As well as being generally hopeless, he is suffering from a mental illness which involves "dead" moods in which he plans killing this woman. Because these moods are intermittent and he has no memory of them when in his right mind, it takes the length of the book for what we know is going to happen to happen. It all seemed a bit like we were supposed to wish Netta dead for not appreciating George. Petty and misogynistic, in other words. (Indeed, looking at other reviews, it seems many readers did want the nice man to kill the nasty woman.) And the descriptions of George's dead moods were repetitive. But there were some scenes that livened the book up, and it's always interesting to see that other ages could be just as seedy. "
— Leonie, 1/18/2014