" I think this is probably the shortest of the Hornblower novels, at only about 155 pages. Still, it's more than enough time for Horatio to expound meaningfully and at length about his Emo Man-Pain. Before I met Horatio - or at least, the book version of him - I did not think it was possible for someone born in the eighteenth century to have Emo Man-Pain. And yet he manages it with aplomb. I consistently want to smack him for his attitude towards Maria, and even more so for his attitude towards Lady Barbara, who is supposedly the love of his life. Never is it more plain than in this book just why the producers of the Hornblower miniseries felt it necessary to add the character of Archie Kennedy; without Archie's influence, Horatio really is insufferable. "
— Siria, 2/11/2014